January 21, 2010

Analysis of the goals conceded against Liverpool

Although we deserved nothing from the game at Anfield last night, we gave away two very poor goals.

First goal.

In the sixth minute, we’re regrouping after a chance of our own. A high ball is played forward – usually Dawson’s forte.
Two things to notice – firstly, Palacios (third from the left, with a good view of play). I find it hard to be critical of Palacios‘ passing, because he wasn’t brought to us to add passing ability. However, I will continue to criticise his lack of defensive nous. Surely a defensive-minded midfielder should see that Aquilani (who he is directly up against for much of the game) is in a position to influence the game should Kuyt win this ball. He can’t just rely on Dawson winning the header.


EDIT: it has been pointed out (correctly) that Dawson slips – you can see from the still above, but more clearly from the video). This allows Kuyt to win the ball unchallenged. However, I still feel that we shouldn’t have conceded that goal, with or without the slip.

Dawson gets tight to Kuyt, and looks favourite to win the ball.

Kuyt is the master of backing into players subtly, and he uses his back-side to manoeuvre himself into a position to lay the ball off to Aquilani, who has carried on his movement (whilst Palacios has virtually stood still).

Aquilani shows good ability to feed the ball back to Kuyt (before getting clattered by Dawson). Personally at this point, I think the King of old would be a yard further forward.

Or at least would now be trying to make up a bit of ground, to give Kuyt less room to get a shot off. Admittedly he takes it early, but frankly, that’s pretty much the only way he can score from this situation, and he does.

Second goal.

Some may argue that it’s difficult to criticise when you’re chasing the game, but this penalty situation is a shambles. Bassong has been on for nine minutes (an utterly bizarre substitution, covered below), and has so far looked very uncomfortable (maybe his shorts are on the wrong way round?).

Darby picks the ball up in the middle of the pitch, and has plenty of room. Bale comes to close him (no wide left player at this point), which gives us a problem, as Bassong and Palacios are left with decisions to make – something they both seem to struggle with.

Darby finds Maxi with a decent ball to feet. Notice now that Bale is out of the game, that N’Gog has shown great anticipation and is pulling into a useful position. Palacios has been attracted towards the ball, and Bassong (edge of out box) is in two minds.

Looking at it from another view, you can analyse better the positioning of our players. Dawson is the deepest, getting back into position having made a clearance. The other defenders are in truly awful positions. Bassong is unable to influence the game, and Hutton is ball-watching.

Maxi slips N’Gog in with a perfectly weighted first time pass.

From above, you can see the danger. Bassong needed to go with N’Gog but hasn’t and, as a result, he’s in acres of space. Hutton is still ball-watching happily.

N’Gog’s first touch is a little heavy, which tempts Bassong into making a challenge. However, because he’s not close enough, he has no chance of getting there.

N’Gog is blessed with excellent pace and athleticism – he touches it beyond Bassong and gets cleaned out, just inside the area.

Kuyt steps up at the second time of asking and sends Gomes the wrong way.

Some general points about the game:

  • Redknapp’s team selection was predictable, but that doesn’t make it right. With Kranjcar and Modric on the flanks, we lack width, and it asks a lot of our full-backs. Kranjcar has been in terrific form, and Modric is probably our best player, so it’s hard not to include both. However, if they are to play in the same side, we must ensure that it’s in a 4-2-3-1, with one striker, and at least one naturally wide player – yesterday we could have played Bale/Bentley/Giovani/Naughton/Rose in an advanced role. Yes, lesser players, but it’s about picking the right team rather than the right individuals.
  • When we had possession, we were often trying to play through a crowded central area (our narrow midfield, plus Lucas, Mascherano and Aquilani), rather than exploiting their weaker flanks (although Bale had some joy).
  • Liverpool have been struggling this season against teams that play at a high tempo, press high, and force them to play the long ball – we didn’t do enough of this as a team, and when we did force Liverpool to play long, we didn’t win first or second balls convincingly (see the first goal).
  • I’ve not been a fan of Redknapp’s substitutions in general, but to bring Bassong on for King with 10 minutes to go at 1-0 was totally bizarre. Firstly, I don’t think King should have started – he looked half-fit, and off the pace. But if he had to come off, why not put on an attacker and ask Palacios to sit in front of Dawson? We needed to go for broke.

Tagged , |

  • Anonymous says:

    Excellent analysis, which leaves me with one conclusion. He was the right man at the time, our house was burning down and we called a fireman, but based on his player recruitment and lack of tactical nous Redknapp is not the man to take us into the promised land!

  • Anonymous says:

    The best start in years was down to the teams we played. Now I look for signs of improvement generally and see none. We are actually worse against the Sky Four away from home now compared to the past few seasons, 3-0 at Chelsea and the Arse, 2-0 against Liverpool, games we used to draw or lose narrowly. Has not addressed familiar problems, lack of leadership and fight on the pitch, no lennon, no width and I’m too fed up to go on. Alternatives, no idea. Do we want to go down the Martin O’Neill long ball game, which we do a lot if we don not have width. Depression!

  • Windy says:

    Please note my edit:

    EDIT: it has been pointed out (correctly) that Dawson slips – you can see from the still above, but more clearly from the video). This allows Kuyt to win the ball unchallenged. However, I still feel that we shouldn’t have conceded that goal, with or without the slip.

  • Anonymous says:

    yep can’t argue with much of that.

  • JimmyG2 says:

    If Defoe’s goal had stood which it should have done the result might have been different. Clutching at straws I know.
    Apart from his poor positional play which you have highlighted before did Palacios even make a tackle? Oh yes I remember he got booked!
    Tactics entirely wrong, the long ball was never likely to work against robust experienced defenders.
    No point in playing skilful midfield players and then hoofing the ball over their heads.

  • JimmyG2 says:

    Windy,
    I am puzzled by Gomes failure to prevent Kyte’s goal. It is struck early ,quite well placed but not fiercely. He seems to be in a good position and doesn’t appear unsighted.
    He has a habit of making early saves to keep us in the game, he did against Leeds yesterday but seems better going to his left than his right.
    I’m not saying he should have saved it but I am surprised that he didn’t.
    Any comments from your photo charts or videos.

  • Windy says:

    Jimmy – it’s a very, very tough one to call. Kuyt took it so early that it was probably unexpected. Also, he did get it right in the corner. Having said that, he didn’t blast it, and it was from a fairly long way out, so Gomes had a good view and perhaps had time to get down to it. If Robinson had conceded it, I imagine there would have been more questions asked.

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

RSS Feed Google+s The Fighting Cock!
 
 

Twitter

RT @thfcacademy: Brief highlights of yesterday's UEFA Youth League draw with Real Madrid: https://t.co/WTLbLDwkPr
9 hours ago