Spurs loanee update – 25/09/11

Follow me on Twitter – @WindyCOYS.

Currently we have the following players out on loan:

Premier League
Steven Caulker – Swansea City (season)
Kyle Naughton – Norwich City (season)
Jermaine Jenas – Aston Villa (season)


Bongani Khumalo – Reading (season)
Ryan Mason – Doncaster (season)
David Bentley – West Ham (season)

League One
Nathan Byrne – Bournemouth (season)
Jon Obika – Yeovil Town (January)
Adam Smith – MK Dons (season)
David Button – Leyton Orient (January)
Ben Alnwick – Leyton Orient (one month)

Simon Dawkins – San Jose Earthquakes (December)
Mirko Ranieri – FC Esperia Viareggio (season)

Now returned:

Oscar Jansson – Bradford City
Kudus Oyenuga – Bury

Steven Caulker had made an excellent start to the season with Swansea City, playing against Man City, Wigan, Sunderland and Arsenal, Swansea’s defence keeping two clean sheets in those games.

Unfortunately, during the Arsenal game he made a goal line clearance and clashed with the woodwork, damaging his knee cartilage in the process. He is expected to miss 6-8 weeks in total, and 2 of those have already passed.

The Swansea fans seem very happy with him so far – some comments from the Swansea forums after the Wigan game:

“An absolute beast today.

Won everything in the air.”

“Can’t believe he’s only 19.

He’s fantastic in the air and very comfortable on the ball”
“He really does impress me, for somebody so young he shows maturity beyond his years football wise”

And after the Sunderland game:

“Is it me or does Caulker look an absolute rolls royce of a centre half”

“Caulker is strong, quick and has good instincts. He’ll be hell of a player in a couple of years.”

Hopefully Steven’s injury will heal quickly and he will be able to get straight back into the swing of things.

Kyle Naughton has forced himself into the Norwich City starting eleven with some impressive showings. Paul Lambert initially seemed keen to stick with Russell Martin at right back, who did so well for them last year, but Naughton has now started four out of five Premier League matches, and has not really put a foot wrong.

He was recently interviewed for a local paper, and said all the right things:

“I haven’t really spoken to Spurs much. When I go out on loan I like to just try to get my head down and concentrate on the club that I’m playing for.”

Jermaine Jenas joined Aston Villa on a season-long loan at the end of the transfer window, but has yet to play a part for them due to niggling injuries. He will be looking to cement himself in the Villa midfield, although has competition from Bannan and Delph.

Bongani Khumalo is currently out of the reckoning at Reading having played the opening five games of the season for them.

There were some relatively good fan comments after his first few games – these after his debut:

“Khumalo – 6.5 not as good as I was expecting but didn’t do a lot wrong.”

“Khumalo – 6 composed and decent in the air but made mistakes”

“Federici then compounds their errors (as he did with the first) and then both Griffin and Khumalo fail to cut out Marquis’ header as you’d hope they might.”

And these after their 2-0 win against Leicester:

“Khumalo – Better than I predicted. Good block.”

“Kumalo – 8 – really good today, won a lot of good headers, took no chances”

“Khumalo also made a superb diving tackle block (think of Sonko’s Superman incident but with legs rather than face) with the Leicester forward having a free shot on goal begging from 10 yards.”

“Khumalo had a stormer today, I like the look of him already.”

“Looked very assured today in the little he had to do. Looked a good relationship between him and Pearce.”

However, things started to turn after the 2-1 home defeat to Barnsley:

“What the hell was Federici doing not coming for that first one!? There was no one in his way. His all the way. Fricking useless. Poor from Khumalo too.”

And after the League Cup defeat against League One Charlton, the comments were even worse:

“our 3 first teamers (Harte, Khumalo and Captain MArvel) were our worst players. Khumalo no control whatsoever (was this one of Redknapp’s dodgy buys???)”

“Too early to write him off, but it is a horrendous start. Positioning woeful, does not look confident, passing slapdash, looks out of his depth, will cost us goals galore.”

“In central defence, Khumalo looks too raw and unpredictable. I have just read a McDermott quote saying we need a central defender to calm us down and that has to refer in part to Khumalo. To be honest I don’t know who was supposed to be marking Euell for his goal but in general I thought Morrison looks slightly the better of the two central defenders”

“Khumalo – 4 Doesn’t seem to be able to judge a header at all, and balls went over him a number of times.”

“Khumalo – 2 no awareness, no positioning, can’t head, can’t mark, can’t pass, can’t control it. Got a bit of pace though.”

He missed last week’s match because he was having his wisdom teeth removed, but played for Reading’s reserves in midweek, so there was talk of him being involved this weekend. He was not named on the bench, however, and so I am starting to wonder why we have not recalled him and sent him elsewhere.

Ryan Mason had a decent start for Doncaster before injury yet again got the better of him. He started in their 2-1 defeat to Brighton, and had a decent game.

A comment on a Doncaster forum:

“Also thought Mason did very well – tried to get on the ball and make things happen. If he can play like that he’ll be an asset this season.”

He then scored in their 3-0 League Cup win against Tranmere, playing off the striker, with a free role in a 4-2-3-1. Unfortunately he was also stretchered off after a bad tackle, later tweeting “Not too happy about the tackle that’s put me on crutches! What can ya do it’s football.. Will let u know how bad it is as soon as I find out”.

A real shame, as the fans were impressed:

Fan comments:

“Gutted, and it took the gloss of a good team performance. Mason was MOM for me, followed by Oster and Bennett.”

“Oster, Gilly and Mason where unplayable in the first half and Browny put himself about.”

“Mason my Motm by a country mile!”

Ryan is now nearing full fitness again, although a lot has changed at Doncaster since he last played, with Sean O’Driscoll sacked and Dean Saunders brought in as manager. Ryan gave this interview to the Doncaster website yesterday:

After six week out of action attacking midfielder Ryan Mason is now ready to get back to playing.

“It’s just good to be back out there on the training pitch”, said Mason.

After a promising start to the season for Ryan, frustration was the emotion going through his head after being stretchered off in only the second game.

“I was gutted.”

“I started the first two games of season, to get injured was probably the worst feeling I’ve had in football – hopefully I’m past that now and I can get some more games under my belt.”

“It frustrating not being able to get involved, I just wanted to get back playing as soon as possible – no footballer likes to be out injured.”

The hard work put in by the back room staff has payed off, with Mason training with the rest of the squad this week.

“If I’m honest its probably tougher being injured, you’re in the earliest and you leave the latest, you’re constantly doing stuff whether it be in the pool or the gym – It’s been a long process but I’m raring to go.”

“I trained Monday and Tuesday, it’s good to be back out there after sitting on the sidelines for six weeks.”

“I want to play; I feel if I’m fit enough to train then I’m fit enough to play.”

“Six weeks out is a long time out to be chucked straight back in – but I think I’m ready if I get called upon.”

Nathan Byrne has had a rocky start to his loan at Bournemouth, and now finds himself on the treatment table as well.

A few fan comments after his debut – very mixed reaction:

“Byrne – Poor debut, hesitant and awful distribution. Hope this was just a bad day for him.”

“Second came from a needlessly conceded corner by Byrne and third Wright-Phillips made a meal of a challenge and turned it into a penalty.”

“Byrne I thought he did ok but where was Feeney in front of him.”

“Lyle Taylor having quite an effect on the game by the sounds of it and was unlucky not to win us a pen. Nathan Byrne impressed as well.”

Fan comments after their 5-0 win against Dagenham & Redbridge:

“After a poorish first half, I thought Byrne had a great second half and linked up well with Feeney.

These two could cause a lot of problems to the opposition as the season progresses and they get to understand each other’s play.”

“byrne had a great second half”

He scored an own goal in a 2-1 defeat to Carlisle:

“Byrne – Doesn’t have the same physical presence as Smith and although he linked up well with Feeney, particularly in the first half, he had a torrid time in the second half when he was often left to defend against two attackers, with very little support from Feeney, or any of the others. I felt a little sorry for him actually. The own goal was not his fault at all (5)”

Having started the season at right back, Nathan found himself pushed into midfield in his last few appearances. He has stated twelve games for Bournemouth, which will stand him in good stead for the rest of the season, but he unfortunately sustained an ankle ligament injury in the win against Exeter.

Jon Obika is another who has had an injury lay-off, which has stopped him playing regularly for Yeovil Town, where he is on loan until January. He played their first three league games, and was a substitute in their League Cup defeat to Exeter, but picked up a knee injury, and may require surgery. He was told to rest for four weeks, at which point he will be sent back to the surgeon, and I read this week that he has returned to Spurs for treatment.

Adam Smith has had a very good start to his season-long loan at MK Dons, playing eight times before picking up a knock.

After his debut, their manager Karl Robinson was full of praise:

Adam Smith was handed his debut for the Dons less than 12 hours after completing his loan move from Tottenham Hotspur, but the right-back looked natural on the ball and more than comfortable in the Dons’ team.

“Adam is a great footballer, he’s classy, elegant, not the biggest but he can play. He can pass, take people on, I really him, he looked like he had been here all pre-season, you wouldn’t think he had trained in a five-a-side yesterday and just turned up to play today.”

Smith’s strong displays have earned him an England U21 call-up, but he recently picked up an ankle injury in a tackle in the game against Huddersfield and has missed a couple of games so far.

David Button is yet another injured loanee. He joined Leyton Orient until January towards the end of August, and played just two games before sustaining a shoulder injury which could keep him out for two months.

There was a nice interview with David on the Leyton Orient website after his debut, where he talks about his friendship with ex-Spur Lee Butcher.

With Button injured, Orient signed Ben Alnwick for a month to cover for him, but now he has got injured too! He played three league games in a week, only to suffer a groin injury and miss the next couple.

The comments about his performances were generally quite positive:

“Had me worried a few times in the first half and his kicking don’t seem all that.

However made a couple of cracking saves in the second.”

“Exactly, one or two stray kicks, his throwing is excellent and his eye for a quick release is great.

Very good keeper who played at championship clubs and done well.”

“Did well but I thought he could have done better for the Col U goal….”

David Bentley has made three substitute appearances for West Ham so far, implying perhaps that he is not up to speed fitness-wise. Allardyce’s comments after his first appearance were quite telling:

“David Bentley came on and his quality of passing opened the opposition up more. The additions before the window shut look exciting, I’ve got to say.”

“Whereas David Bentley, Joey O’Brien and George McCartney had basically been discarded by the clubs they were at and had not got the right amount of training, so it’ll take some time for them to catch up.”

This week he was relatively complimentary again:

“The substitutes made us even better and John Carew looked more like his old self; David Bentley came on as well and gave us a bit more down the right, not that I was disappointed in Carlton Cole or Julien Faubert. But it’s nice to know your subs can come up and take things a little higher again.”

Simon Dawkins is a regular starter for San Jose Earthquakes, where he is on loan until December. He has now made 15 starts and 7 substitute appearances for them since March, including five starts in a row since the end of August.

Dawkins was recently included in an article called “24 under 24” on the MLS website:

One of the most exciting new arrivals of 2011 in MLS. The Englishman — on loan from the EPL’s Tottenham Hotspur — has shown he is capable of providing a jolt to the Earthquakes attack with his ability to keep opposing defenses on their heels. His speed, quickness and aggressive dribbling have made him an ideal support forward or playmaker, helping to fill the void left by the departure of Geovanni. However, injury setbacks have limited Dawkins’ contributions after he got off to an explosive start to the campaign.

What the TDs and coaches say: “Excellent dribbler who can break guys down on the dribble … He’s not a guy you want running at you … Scores and he’s hungry for it … When he’s on, he’s a difference-maker on the field and it’s all based on the dribble. He’s a decent passer, but it’s all about the ball being at his feet … He looks to pull the trigger and if you give him time and space he can hurt you … If he’s not facing the goal, he’s less of a threat. His weakness is playing with his back to goal.”

Oscar Jansson has returned to us from Bradford City having made just three appearances. In his debut he was thrown into a local derby with Leeds in the League Cup, where he had a decent game and wasn’t at fault for any of the three goals conceded. He was released by Bradford after they signed the experienced Matt Duke at the end of the transfer window, with manager Phil Parkinson making positive noises:

“I’d like to thank Oscar for all his efforts during his time here.

In the short period that I’ve been at the club, he has been no problems at all and always trained in a professional manner.

I am sure that fans will remember Oscar fondly, especially thanks to his penalty saves in the Sheffield Wednesday match

Unfortunately for Oscar though, we cannot sustain three goalkeepers on books at the moment with Dukey and Jon [McLaughlin] here as well.”

Kudus Oyenuga returned to us at the end of his one month loan with Bury having made three appearances – substitute appearances in League One and the League Cup, and a start in the Johnstones Paint Trophy. He will be looking for another loan move as soon as possible, and has been linked with Exeter.

Young goalkeeper Mirko Ranieri is on loan at FC Esperia Viareggio in the third tier of Italian football. Funnily enough I have not been able to find any information on his progress there!

Join the conversation

  1. Cheers windy!
    Always pleased to read your loanee updates, shame about all the unjuries atm though
  2. Hey Windy who ever you are, great work, how nice to get updates on our future stars.
    Comments from fans and managers gives you a really good insight into how they are doing.
    Keep up the good work... looking forward to the next episode.

  3. Top work Windy, thanks.
  4. Thanks for the research on all the loanees - good work.

    Mirco Ranieri seems to have played all 3 of FC Esperia Viareggio's matches so far this season.


  5. Thanks Windy. Thorough as usual. I have pasted your info onto Triffic Tottenhan Forum to keep everyone up to date. Hope that's OK. I have put your name on it so they know it's your work, if you want me to remove it just let me know.

  6. Great stuff as always Windy; our players seem to get injured as much when they are on loan as back at the Lane!

    Cyril (COYS)
  7. Windy- It really sounds like Caulker could be a good one for the future. If you had to rate his potential what would you say he is capable of becoming? Could he reach the level of Kaboul? Or Dawson? Even the great Ledley King? Thanks for the fantastic work, always top notch.
  8. Thanks for all the info, really great blog you have here. If you had to rate all of Spurs' youth/academy players (pritchard, luongo, carroll, mason, etc.) who would you say has the best chance of being a star with the first team, and just how good do you think they could become?
  9. Awesome work and research Windy.
    Many thanks.

    Makes me wonder what is going to happen to Jenas though, on loan, injured - not going to help his career at all.
  10. Anon @ 19:19 - Cheers! Hopefully a few will get back to fitness soon - I know Mason's nearly ready. Byrne could take a bit longer...and if Obika needs an op he'll be out a while too unfortunately.

    Bobby - cheers! I always enjoy writing loanee updates, especially if there are nice comments to read on loanee club forums.

    Anon @ 19:39 - pleasure!

    Spursidol - much appreciated! Will keep their official site in mind for next time. Good to hear he's playing.

    Foggy - Of course, that's fine - thanks for spreading the word!

    Cyril - It's a concern of mine - so many injuries throughout our squad already... thanks for the comment as ever!

    Anon @ 02:17 - I think he could be anything - he has all the raw materials, and seemingly the attitude/maturity. If he works hard enough he could be an England CB for years to come IMO.

    Jebediah - thanks for your comment, very much appreciated! I'd say Caulker is the most obvious. Redknapp seems to really like Carroll, so he should get chances this year, which could push him to the next in the pecking order. I'd love to see Mason "make it" for Spurs, because he's a local (ish) lad, and I believe a Spurs fan. He's also a cracking player who, like Carroll, plays the game the right way. To be honest, a number of them have a chance - Townsend, Mason, Smith and Parrett of the slightly older ones, then Luongo, Pritchard, have a chance too - they just need that break-through moment.

    SpursSimon - concerns me too - really not sure how a loan helps us. Hopefully it will be made permanent, for both our sakes. He needs a fresh start.
  11. I find it strange that two of our younger keepers are out injured.

    As always, fantastic work Windy! Thanks!
  12. What kind of player is Luongo? Carroll?

    In your opinion who is Spurs top defender?

    If we are priced out of Damiao who should we buy in January (assuming we sell
    Pav)? Negredo?

  13. elwehbi@ibleedhotspur - Thank you, very much appreciated! Re: two goalkeepers, I think I read that Button's was a heavy landing in training. Alnwick suffering a groin injury seems somewhat ironic given past infamy.

    Lemon172 - Luongo is pretty all-action - likes a tackle, but keeps the ball really well and has a decent eye for a pass. Carroll is a very cultured player - rarely gives the ball away, great technique, always wanting to get on the ball.

    Damiao should be top target - presumably we've done some of the groundwork? Negredo is a good player - already has 3 in 5 this season. Would command a large fee too though, surely?
  14. Any good young strikers we should buy?

    Your blog is AWESOME!!!!!!!!

  15. Windy, what are your thoughts on the recent comments on John Bostock not being on the Europa B-List due to a technicality concerning time spent on loan? or even your thoughts on Bostock in general?
  16. Lârryböy - Cheers! Nice of you to say! Leandro Damiao?

    bonse - Sounds logical - not been at the club for 36 months. Can see why that rule is in place - means genuine home-grown players are more likely to get a chance. I think Bostock's good technically, with question marks over his attitude, and also over how he fits into a team (as in, literally - position wise - and also teamwork wise).


Your email address will not be published.