Young professionals – progress check
Follow me on Twitter – @WindyCOYS.
You can also hear me on The Fighting Cock podcast.
A number of players from Tim Sherwood’s “Development Squad” (this name seems to be catching on across the football world!) have made their first team debuts this season, so it seems a good time to consider the progress of some of them.
Jake Livermore, 21
Livermore is proving me wrong. I had totally written him off as a Spurs player, and was surprised when Redknapp started to use him in the first team squad in pre-season. I always felt that in the U18s and reserves that he lacked technique and genuine footballing ability, and was primarily making faster progress than others due to his physical attributes. Whilst he is clearly not the best technically, he has shown that he is, at the very least, competent and reliable in his Premier League and Europa League appearances. He is keen to get on the ball when we have possession, but also not afraid of puting in a shift and doing his share of the dirty work.
His main strength is still probably his physicality – he’s big, strong, and has good energy levels – but he has also shown good positional awareness and showed in his goal against Hearts that he does have some footballing ability too! I still don’t see him becoming a Spurs regular, but he should certainly be able to carve out a Premier League career for himself.
Tom Carroll, 19
There have been many comments from fans, the media and Harry Redknapp about him looking like a boy, but Carroll plays the game like a seasoned pro. His touch, movement and awareness are excellent – always looking to make himself available to receive the ball, and then quickly distributing it, before he again looks to find a suitable space. When he loses the ball (which has not been too often in his performances for the first team so far), he doesn’t recklessly dive into a challenge – instead, he puts the maximum effort into getting back behind the ball and stopping the opposition from playing.
One criticism so far would be that he has perhaps kept it too simple – his passing range is such that he should perhaps look to be a little more ambitious at times but, on the other hand, it’s totally understandable that he would look firstly to play himself into a game with simple passing, and secondly, look to impress the manager with his ability to keep the ball.
Whilst I rate Carroll as an excellent prospect, we must be patient with him – look at Manchester United’s handling of Tom Cleverley (who is three years older than Carroll) as a comparison – he had lengthy loan spells before getting a chance in their first team.
Andros Townsend, 20
Having made a superb goal-scoring debut in the FA Cup match against Charlton last season, Townsend impressed on loan at Millwall and will certainly feel that he has earned his chance in our first team. He will be disappointed, however, that most of his opportunities have come at left-back, with Danny Rose out injured and Assou-Ekotto rested. However, he came on and really influenced the game when given his chance on the wing against Shamrock Rovers, getting an assist and generally looking lively.
I am not sure whether he will feel that he may have been better off going straight out on loan this season, or whether he will be pleased to have had first team football for Spurs in any position. There is plenty of the season left, so he should still get a loan move – hopefully to a lower-half Premier League team, or an upper-half Championship team – where he can continue to progress.
Ryan Fredericks, 19
Fredericks was on the bench for the first team in the 2009/10 season in the FA Cup Fourth Round replay against Leeds, but soon after he picked up a long-term injury, which meant him missing the majority of the 2010/11 season. To start against Hearts in the Europa League, then, must have come as quite a surprise – he was barely back to fitness! Fredericks is blessed with natural pace, and has good close control and crossing ability, although he didn’t really get much of a chance to showcase much of his attacking play in his second start (against Rubin Kazan), which came at right back, a position that he has occasionally played for the Development Squad.
He will be looking for more involvement in the Europa League, before heading out on loan in order to get some league experience and to build up his strength and fitness.
Harry Kane, 18
The youngest of all of our players who have been involved with our first team squad this season – he only turned 18 at the end of July, a month before his first team debut. He did OK in his debut, although was left wondering what could have been, missing a penalty that he had won himself. In his second appearance he was very unfortunate not to win another penalty and was instead incorrectly shown a yellow card for simulation.
Kane has an ungainly style, but his touch is good and he has plenty of strength for one so young. He has scored goals at youth and reserve level, and also had a reasonable scoring record for League One side Leyton Orient last year. I think a lot of fans were expecting more from him in his Europa League showings, but it is important to remember that he is still very young and inexperienced – time is on his side.
Dean Parrett, 19
Parrett made his debut against Shakhtar in February 2009 – he put in a very tidy performance in that game and will feel a little unlucky that he has not seen more first team involvement, making just three further substitute appearances. Parrett will hopefully get a chance in the remaining Europa League matches, but the emergence of Livermore and Carroll, plus injury problems of his own, have meant that he has found himself (rightly or wrongly) a little way down the pecking order.
An all-action player, Parrett possesses great drive and no little technique, with good all-round football ability. He turns 20 soon, and will certainly be looking for first-team football this year, be it for us in the Europa League or on loan.
Ineligible Europa League players
A number of fans have been questioning why the likes of John Bostock, Massimo Luongo, Cristian Cellabos and Souleymane Coulibaly are not involved in the Europa League. In order to qualify for the UEFA “B List”, a player must have been born after 1st January 1990 and have been registered with the club for two years since his 15th birthday. This obviously rules out the likes of Luongo, Ceballos and Coulibaly, all more recent signings, but also Bostock due to his loan spells away from the club. They could have been named in the main “A List” (as Iago Falqué, Giovani dos Santos and Jake Livermore were), but that would have to have been at the expense of first-team players. To illustrate, here is the squad list taken from the UEFA Europa League website.
To round-up, here is a line on the progress of each of our other young professionals (from the list on the official site):
Ben Alnwick, 24 – currently on loan at Leyton Orient as cover for the injured David Button. He has made five appearances so far.
Jordan Archer, 18 – on loan at Bishop’s Stortford and performing well – he is also a recently call up to the Scotland U21 squad.
David Button, 22 – was having a good start to life on loan at Leyton Orient until he picked up a shoulder injury in September.
Oscar Jansson, 20 – playing on a near-weekly basis for the Spurs XI (reserve team) following the completion of his loan at Bradford.
Mirko Ranieri, 19 – on a season-long loan at Italian side FC Esperia Viareggio, presumably with one eye on a permanent move.
Nathan Byrne, 19 – had started to settle after a tough opening spell at Bournemouth, but suffered a serious ankle ligament injury and will miss a couple more months of football.
Steven Caulker, 19 – was playing consistently well for Swansea City prior to his knee cartilage injury, but is due back soon.
Bongani Khumalo, 24 – having initially been a regular starter at Reading, he has found himself down the pecking order of late, and is fighting to get his place back.
Kyle Naughton, 23 – a regular starter at right-back for Norwich, with a decent level of consistency to his performances.
Adam Smith, 20 – has been performing very well for MK Dons, and recently picked up three MOTM awards in a row (one having scored a superb goal). He has recently been called up to (and played for) England U21s.
John Bostock, 19 – has been playing in some of the NextGen Series and for the Spurs XI.
Cristian Ceballos, 18 – scored the opener in the 4-1 win over PSV in the NextGen Series and for the Spurs XI.
Yago Falqué, 21 – on a season-long loan with an option to make the move permanent, he has been heavily involved in the Europa League and has shown flashes of good play without ever really influencing a match.
Massimo Luongo, 19 – made his first-team debut, coming off the bench in the League Cup game against Stoke, and unfortunately missing a penalty. I think he will get more chances this season – an impressive player, and one to watch.
Ryan Mason, 20 – on loan at Doncaster although he has again seen his loan spell disrupted by injury problems. Doncaster have changed their manager (with Dean Saunders taking over) and so we need to wait and see whether he’ll be involved in their first team on a regular basis.
Jake Nicholson, 19 – has played in NextGen Series matches, Spurs XI matches, and came off the bench in the Europa League – he will certainly be looking for a taste of league football this year.
Alex Pritchard, 18 – one of the stars of our NextGen Series team so far with some excellent performances, and he has also been an unused sub in two Europa League games.
Jesse Waller-Lassen, 18 – still getting over injury problems, although nearing full fitness – I’d expect that Jesse be given time to get up to speed with appearances for the Spurs XI.
Simon Dawkins, 23 – returned from a good spell with San Jose Earthquakes in the MLS – he finished an impressive 21st in the Castrol Index Player of the Season rankings (his team mate Chris Wondolowski was 1st, Thierry Henry was 3rd, Landon Donovan was 16th, Juan Pablo Angel was 25th, David Beckham was 69th).
Cameron Lancaster, 19 – scored a good goal for the Spurs XI last week, and was on the bench for the Europa League match with Rubin Kazan.
Jonathan Obika, 21 – still on loan at Yeovil, although just on his way back from injury.
Kudus Oyenuga, 18 – involved in some of the NextGen Series games, and some Spurs XI games, Kudus will be looking for more league experience after he only got a few brief appearances at Bury.